GM Bennies are... Bad?!Not necessarily. GM bennies can bring a lot of value and fun to an encounter, making the experience of the challenge a memorable one, but let me give an example scenario that illustrates where GM bennies can have a negative impact.
A couple of game sessions ago, my players faced a very challenging encounter that cost the life of one of the player characters. Some of that challenge was related to the toughness of the creature, and some of it was because of GM and Wild Card bennies. Ron had a similar situation in one of his games. Coincidentally, we were both dealing the same creature, a Tyrannosaurus Rex, except his was undead. Our shared sentiment was that GM bennies, can steal the thunder from the players and drag the encounter on longer than what's really necessary for the story. And if the encounter is the last one for the session, the GM might have a stack of bennies (i.e., one for each player and two for the Wild Card) to use at will.
Whenever a GM uses a benny, it immediately creates a GM-vs-players dynamic. That method of GMing is not one I enjoy. I like challenging my players, but I don't like being antagonistic toward them in the gaming sense. Additionally, when facing a creature with a high toughness, which typically requires quite a few attacks to get in just one wound (let alone four), using a benny to Soak wounds extends the combat even longer and takes away an achievement the players worked hard to earn.
Sure, a GM can simply self-inhibit the use of bennies, but I would suggest a prescribed limitation that creates more of a strategic challenge for the GM.
SolutionsInstead of having the usual pool of bennies at the beginning of the session, Ron and I are considering using one of the changes below for our respective games. Note that in each of the scenarios below, the GM does not get one benny for each player at the beginning of the session.
- The GM still has two bennies for each of his NPC Wild Cards to use, and is encouraged to use them for rerolls and removing the Shaken status, but not for Soaking.
- As above, but the GM only gets one benny for each of his NPC Wild Cards. This makes the use of a benny more strategic and impacting.
- NPC Wild Cards have no bennies, but the GM gets a benny when a player uses a benny in such a way that allows the GM to gain one in exchange. (e.g., Red Fate Chips in Deadlands, or Khyber (blue) Prophecy Shards in Savage Eberron).
Whether you agree or disagree, drop a line, and let me know what you think about GM bennies in Savage Worlds.